| Year | 1st Team | 2nd Team |
| 2001 | Shawn Kelly, Sarah Piazza | Becca Fraizer |
| 2002 | Molly Zeliff | |
| 2003 | Berkeley Adinger-Gibson, Molly Zeliff, Anna Hartz, Sarah Marks | Becca Frazier |
| 2004 | Berkeley Adinger-Gibson, Viv Gaddis, Molly Zeliff, | Anna Hartz Sarah Marks |
| 2005 | Amy Chapman | |
| 2006 | Shelley Chestler, Lauren Ohlson | Emily Fuller, Maura Throckmorton, Kathleen Preston |
| 2007 | Tate Murray, Latane Cox, Lauren Ohlson | Emily Fuller |
| 2008 | Tate Murray | Jocelyn Aguilar, Sarah Morse, Emily Hoard |
| 2009 | Tate Murray, Latane Cox | Emily Gaddis |
